Maytag Refrigerator: not cooling properly

Professional Repair Guide

What is this symptom?

Is your Maytag refrigerator not cooling properly? If the interior temperatures are warmer than expected while lights and controls seem functional, you might be facing issues like dirty condenser coils or malfunctioning fan motors. This problem can lead to the freezer being cold while the fridge remains warm, affecting food preservation.

Urgency: Medium

Important Tips for Maytag Models

  • Some Maytag refrigerators were part of a defect settlement related to frost build-up on evaporator interfering with cooling.

Possible Causes

Dirty condenser coils hindering heat dissipation

How to Identify: Inspect coils (back/under fridge for dust, pet hair; feel if very hot; poor cooling with compressor running.

Part: Condenser coils

Faulty evaporator or condenser fan motor

How to Identify: Freezer cold but fridge warm suggests evaporator fan failure; no airflow or unusual noise; condenser fan not spinning affecting overall cooling. (Appliance Parts Pros

Part: Evaporator fan motor; condenser fan motor

Damper control assembly stuck or faulty (affects air distribution)

How to Identify: Freezer cool but fresh-food section warm; opening fridge not hearing damper operation noises; blocked airflow. (Appliance Parts Pros

Part: Damper control assembly

Start relay/capacitor or compressor issues

How to Identify: No compressor crank sound, clicking or failure to start, constant running without temperature drop. (Appliance Parts Pros

Part: Start relay; compressor

Thermostat or control board malfunction

How to Identify: Incorrect cycling, fridge not responding to temp setting changes, unpredictable cooling behavior. turn(Appliance Parts Pros

Part: Thermostat; temperature control board

Defrost system failure leading to frost build-up on evaporator coils

How to Identify: Frost buildup behind freezer panel restricting airflow; reduced cooling; need thaw. turn(Appliance Parts Pros

Part: Defrost heater/thermostat

DIY Solutions

Clean condenser coils

Moderate 15-30 minutes
Tools Needed: vacuum with brush attachment, coil brush
  1. Unplug refrigerator and locate condenser coils (back or underneath).
  2. Use brush and vacuum to remove dust/debris from coils and surrounding area.
  3. Replug fridge and monitor cooling performance.
⚠️ Safety First: Always disconnect power before cleaning to avoid shock.

Check airflow inside fridge and vents

Easy 5-10 minutes
  1. Remove items blocking air vents inside fridge/freezer.
  2. Ensure food not overpacked to allow cold air circulation.
  3. Close doors and monitor for improvement.

Inspect and test evaporator/condenser fans

Advanced 30-60 minutes
Tools Needed: screwdriver, multimeter
  1. Unplug fridge and remove access panels to locate fans.
  2. Manually check if blades turn freely.
  3. Use multimeter to test motor continuity; replace if no continuity.
⚠️ Safety First: Ensure power is off when accessing internal parts.

Check and adjust temperature settings

Easy 5 minutes
  1. Locate temperature controls inside fridge.
  2. Ensure thermostat is set to recommended range (e.g., mid-range).
  3. Wait 24 hours to see if temperatures stabilize.

Professional Repairs

Replace faulty fan motors (evaporator or condenser)

Estimated Cost: $80 - $250 parts + labor

Replace start relay/capacitor or compressor service

Estimated Cost: $150 - $800+ depending on part

Replace control board or thermostat

Estimated Cost: $100 - $400 parts + labor

Defrost system component replacement

Estimated Cost: $80 - $300 parts + labor

When to Call a Professional

Cooling doesn’t improve after cleaning coils and checking airflow
Compressor won’t start or makes unusual noise
Fan motors do not operate after testing
Control board or sealed system suspected

Preventive Maintenance

  • Clean condenser coils: Heat dissipation issues reducing cooling efficiency
    Frequency: biannually
  • Maintain clear airflow around fridge: Poor ventilation and overheating of cooling system
    Frequency: ongoing

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my Maytag Refrigerator not cooling properly?
Common causes include dirty condenser coils, faulty fan motors, and thermostat issues.
How do I fix Maytag Refrigerator not cooling properly myself?
Start by cleaning the condenser coils and checking airflow. Adjust temperature settings as needed.
How much does it cost to fix not cooling properly?
Professional repair costs can range from $80 to over $800, depending on the issue.
When should I call a technician for not cooling properly?
If DIY solutions don’t resolve the issue within 24 hours, or if you're facing complex repairs.

References & Sources

Community Analytical Insights

Analysis based on real user discussions from appliance repair communities

Can I Fix This Myself?

67%
DIY Success Rate Difficulty: Either

Common Issues Reported by Users

  • Thermostat issues (2 mentions)
  • Evaporator fan problems (2 mentions)
  • Control board malfunction (1 mentions)
  • Starter relay failure (1 mentions)

User Suggested Solutions

  1. Replace evaporator fan and thermostat

    Success rate: 11.0%

  2. Replace thermistor

    Success rate: 11.0%

  3. Replace control board if compressor does not shut down during defrost cycle

    Success rate: 11.0%

  4. Check and potentially replace starter relay

    Success rate: 11.0%
Analysis based on 6 community discussions
View Sources

Data compiled from real discussions on r/appliancerepair and r/Appliances:

  1. Can Someone Explain how a fridge air damper works?
  2. Refrigerator Freezing Food - Will it work without thermistor...
  3. Refrigerator constantly running and getting too cold
  4. Sanity check with Maytag refrigerator
  5. Repair my Refrigerator?
  6. Maytag Fridge, freezing in fridge portion

Community Discussions

running a lot of the time and running too cold

Replace the fridge instead of attempting a DIY repair on the sealed system.

Pro needed View on Reddit →

Freezer was very cold, but fridge was warm. No air was coming out of the vent at the top of the fridge. The evaporator coil was completely iced over.

Replace the control board if the compressor does not shut down during the defrost cycle.

DIY View on Reddit →

Cooling but not cold enough, clicking noise heard

Possible bad starter relay causing compressor issues.

DIY View on Reddit →

Fridge gets warm while freezer stays cold

Replaced evaporator fan and thermostat, resolved cooling issues.

DIY View on Reddit →

Refrigerator freezing food

User plans to replace the thermistor as a potential fix.

DIY View on Reddit →

Source: Reddit r/appliancerepair

User Comments (0)

Share your experience or solution below.

Be the first to comment!