Kenmore Refrigerator: not maintaining temperature

Professional Repair Guide

What is this symptom?

Is your Kenmore refrigerator struggling to maintain the set temperature? This issue often results in warmer food, melting ice cream, and longer running times. Typically, the freezer remains cold while the refrigerator section suffers, indicating airflow or defrost problems. Understanding the common causes can help you troubleshoot effectively.

Urgency: High

Important Tips for Kenmore Models

  • Kenmore troubleshooting patterns frequently emphasize the 'freezer cold but refrigerator warm' scenario, commonly linked to evaporator fan, damper, or defrost-related airflow issues rather than immediate compressor failure.

Possible Causes

Dirty condenser coils

How to Identify: Coils visibly coated with dust/pet hair; refrigerator runs longer than usual; cabinet sides feel hot; cooling gradually worsens over weeks/months

Part: Condenser coils (usually under the unit or behind the rear panel)

Evaporator fan motor not running or obstructed (freezer may cool but fridge warms due to lack of air circulation)

How to Identify: Freezer cold but refrigerator warm; little/no airflow from fridge vents; fan not audible when freezer door switch is pressed; may hear intermittent squealing/grinding if failing

Part: Evaporator fan motor (inside freezer compartment, behind rear panel)

Defrost system failure causing evaporator coil icing (blocks airflow and reduces cooling over time)

How to Identify: Frost/ice buildup on freezer back wall; airflow weak; temperature gets worse after several days then temporarily improves after manual defrost; freezer may start warming too if severe

Part: Defrost heater, defrost thermostat/bimetal, defrost control (timer or electronic control board)

Condenser fan motor not running (poor heat removal leads to warming and compressor overheating)

How to Identify: Fan not spinning while compressor is running; hot compressor area; poor cooling; sometimes rattling noise; dust buildup may also stop the blade

Part: Condenser fan motor (near compressor, rear bottom area)

Air damper/air diffuser stuck closed or blocked (freezer cold, fridge warm)

How to Identify: Freezer maintains temperature while refrigerator warms; minimal airflow into refrigerator even though evaporator fan works; damper may be visibly stuck or noisy when trying to actuate

Part: Damper control assembly (between freezer and refrigerator sections)

Door gasket leak (warm air infiltration causing temperature rise and excess frost)

How to Identify: Visible gaps/tears; paper-strip test fails (paper slides out easily; condensation around door frame; frost accumulation inside

Part: Door gasket/seal

Thermistor/temperature sensor drift or failure (incorrect temperature readings leading to unstable cooling)

How to Identify: Temperature display doesn’t match measured temperature; unit runs too long or cycles incorrectly; temperature swings without obvious airflow issues; may show error codes on some models

Part: Thermistor / temperature sensor

Control board issue (temperature control board or main control board not regulating compressor/fans correctly)

How to Identify: Fans and compressor behave erratically; temperature swings with no clear mechanical cause; may have intermittent operation; sometimes accompanied by clicking relays without stable cooling

Part: Main control board / temperature control board

Sealed system problem (refrigerant leak, weak compressor, restriction) leading to chronic inability to maintain temp

How to Identify: Both sections warm; compressor runs continuously; very little frost pattern on evaporator (partial frost only; condenser may not get warm; no improvement after cleaning coils and confirming fans/defrost

Part: Compressor, evaporator, condenser, refrigerant lines (sealed system)

DIY Solutions

Clean condenser coils to restore heat exchange

Easy 15-30 minutes
Tools Needed: Vacuum with hose attachment, Condenser coil brush, Flashlight
  1. Unplug the refrigerator (or switch off breaker).
  2. Locate condenser coils (behind rear panel or underneath front toe-kick).
  3. Brush loose dust/pet hair from coils and surrounding area.
  4. Vacuum debris thoroughly; ensure airflow paths are clear.
  5. Restore power and monitor temperatures for 12–24 hours.
⚠️ Safety First: Always unplug before cleaning to prevent electric shock or fan injury.

Check for blocked vents and overpacking (restore airflow between freezer and refrigerator)

Easy 10-20 minutes
Tools Needed: Flashlight
  1. Identify interior air vents (usually back wall of refrigerator section).
  2. Move items away from vents; leave several inches of clearance.
  3. Ensure freezer vents are not blocked by packages or ice buildup.
  4. After rearranging, allow 12–24 hours for temperatures to stabilize.
⚠️ Safety First: Do not puncture interior panels to remove ice; refrigerant lines may be behind them.

Verify evaporator fan operation (freezer-to-fridge airflow)

Moderate 10-25 minutes
Tools Needed: Flashlight, Screwdriver set (if access panel removal needed)
  1. Open freezer door and listen for the evaporator fan running.
  2. Press and hold the freezer door switch to simulate a closed door (fan should run on many models).
  3. If the fan is silent, check for ice obstruction behind the freezer rear panel.
  4. If obstructed by ice, perform a full manual defrost and recheck cooling.
⚠️ Safety First: Unplug before removing panels.

Inspect door gaskets and correct sealing problems

Easy 10-20 minutes
Tools Needed: Paper strip (for seal test), Warm soapy water, Towel
  1. Visually inspect gasket for tears, gaps, or hardened sections.
  2. Perform paper test: close door on a strip of paper and pull; resistance should be consistent around the door.
  3. Clean gasket and door sealing surface with warm soapy water and dry.
  4. If gasket is warped, gently warm with a hair dryer on low from a safe distance and reshape.
  5. If torn or not sealing after cleaning, plan gasket replacement.
⚠️ Safety First: Do not overheat gasket with a hair dryer; keep heat moving to avoid damage.

Professional Repairs

Replace evaporator fan motor (restores air circulation)

Estimated Cost: $150 - $350

Repair defrost system (heater, thermostat/bimetal, or defrost control/board)

Estimated Cost: $200 - $500

Replace condenser fan motor (prevents overheating and restores heat removal)

Estimated Cost: $150 - $350

Replace damper control assembly (fixes freezer-cold / fridge-warm due to blocked air path)

Estimated Cost: $200 - $450

Diagnose/replace thermistor or control board (temperature sensing/regulation fault)

Estimated Cost: $200 - $600

Sealed system repair (refrigerant leak, compressor replacement, or restriction clearing)

Estimated Cost: $500 - $1500+

When to Call a Professional

Refrigerator temperature stays above 40°F for more than 4 hours despite basic airflow and coil cleaning steps (food safety risk).
Visible heavy frost/ice returns quickly after a full manual defrost (strong indicator of defrost system failure).
Evaporator or condenser fan does not run (or makes grinding/squealing noises) and you are not comfortable removing panels or testing parts.
You see signs of sealed-system issues: weak or uneven evaporator frost pattern, compressor running constantly with little cooling, or suspected refrigerant leak.
Electrical burning smell, repeated clicking, or tripped breakers (stop using and call a technician).

Preventive Maintenance

  • Clean condenser coils to maintain efficient heat exchange: Gradual loss of cooling capacity and temperature instability
    Frequency: Every 6–12 months (more often with pets/dust)
  • Keep interior vents unobstructed and avoid overpacking: Warm refrigerator section and uneven cooling
    Frequency: Ongoing (weekly check)
  • Inspect and clean door gaskets and sealing surfaces: Warm air infiltration, condensation, frost buildup, and temperature fluctuation
    Frequency: Every 3 months

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my Kenmore Refrigerator not maintaining temperature?
Common causes include dirty condenser coils, a malfunctioning evaporator fan, or defrost system failures.
How do I fix Kenmore Refrigerator not maintaining temperature myself?
Start by cleaning the condenser coils, checking for blocked vents, and verifying the evaporator fan operation.
How much does it cost to fix not maintaining temperature?
Professional repair costs range from $150 to $1500+, depending on the issue severity.
When should I call a technician for not maintaining temperature?
Call a technician if DIY fixes don't resolve the issue, especially if you suspect sealed system problems.

References & Sources

Community Analytical Insights

Analysis based on real user discussions from appliance repair communities

Can I Fix This Myself?

50%
DIY Success Rate Difficulty: Professional

Common Issues Reported by Users

  • Thermostat issue (2 mentions)
  • Compressor failure (1 mentions)

User Suggested Solutions

  1. Possible thermostat issue causing the compressor to not run consistently.

    Success rate: 33.0%

  2. Manufacturer may replace it for free due to a known defect.

    Success rate: 33.0%
Analysis based on 3 community discussions
View Sources

Data compiled from real discussions on r/appliancerepair and r/Appliances:

  1. 2003 Kenmore Refrigerator not maintaining temps (Model 106.5...
  2. Kenmore Refrigerator isn't maintaining temperature, also cyc...
  3. Kenmore elite with big rust spot on rear and failure to main...

Community Discussions

big rust spot on rear and failure to maintain thermostat temp

Manufacturer may replace it for free due to a known defect.

Pro needed View on Reddit →

not maintaining temps

Possible thermostat issue causing the compressor to not run consistently.

DIY View on Reddit →

Source: Reddit r/appliancerepair

User Comments (0)

Share your experience or solution below.

Be the first to comment!